Cardio vs. Strength Training: Which is Better for Brain Health?

Introduction: The Impact of Exercise on Brain Health

[00:00] You might think that lifting weights is just for building muscle, while cardio is what you need for brain health. And this common misconception leads many people to focus solely on cardio when exercising for mental well-being. But the reality is more complex and more interesting. Today we'll see how different types of exercise

Overview of Exercise Benefits for Mental Health

[00:20] affect your brain and mental health in unique ways. I'm Dr. Tracey Marks, a psychiatrist, and I make mental health education videos to strengthen your mind, fortify your brain, and build resilience. Our last video covered how exercise generally changes your brain. Today, we're looking at the specific benefits of different types of

Cardiovascular Exercise and Its Effects on the Brain

[00:40] Let's start with cardiovascular exercise. Cardio includes any activity that keeps your heart rate elevated for an extended period, things like running, swimming, cycling, or brisk walking. What sets cardio apart is its focus on sustaining movement, which significantly boosts blood flow and oxygen.

[01:00] delivery to the brain. Within the first 30 minutes of moderate cardio, your brain experiences a surge in neurotransmitters, particularly dopamine, serotonin, and norepinephrine. This explains the immediate mood boost that many people will feel during and after cardio exercise. But the benefits go

[01:20] far beyond just feeling good. Studies using functional MRI scans show that regular cardio exercises have stronger connections between their prefrontal cortex and amygdala. Think of this like upgrading the communication line between your brain's emotional control center and its alarm system. Better communication

[01:40] medications means better emotional regulation and stress resilience. Cardio also has some unique long-term effects on anxiety and depression. Studies consistently show that regular cardio exercise significantly reduces the risk of developing mental health conditions. A comprehensive meta-analysis that I'll have linked in

[02:00] this description, found that people with high levels of physical activity had 17% lower odds of developing depression compared to those with low activity levels. And it's not just depression. Regular exercise shows similar protective effects against anxiety disorders, with some studies suggesting

[02:20] the benefits may be even greater for anxiety than for depression. The optimal dose, if you will, for mental health benefits is 150 to 300 minutes of moderate intensity aerobic activity per week, or 75 to 150 minutes of vigorous activity.

Strength Training and Its Cognitive and Emotional Benefits

[02:40] Benefits start to plateau after this point of 300 minutes, and more than 300 minutes of vigorous exercise can actually increase stress and anxiety. So that's cardio exercise. Now let's look at strength training, which historically has been underappreciated for its brain benefits. Strength training includes any

[03:00] exercise that uses resistance to build muscle strength, whether that's lifting weights, using resistance bands, or doing body weight exercises like push-ups and squats. Unlike cardio, which focuses on endurance, strength training is about short bursts of intense effort. What makes strength training unique is its impact

[03:20] impact on certain growth hormones in your brain, particularly IGF-1, which stands for insulin-like growth factor I. While cardio primarily boosts brain-derived neurotropic factor, or BDNF, strength training triggers a cascade of growth factors and testosterone that support brain cell

[03:40] survival and enhance your brain's ability to form new connections called synaptic plasticity. It can also help regulate cortisol levels, potentially reducing the negative effects of stress on the brain. Here's another interesting point. Strength training appears to be especially effective at reducing inflammation

[04:00] in the brain. Research in the Journal of Applied Physiology demonstrated that regular resistance exercise significantly decreases key inflammatory markers like C-reactive protein and TNF alpha. This reduction in inflammation may help protect against depression, anxiety, and cognitive

[04:20] cognitive decline. As you probably know from previous videos where I've talked about this, chronic inflammation has been linked to these conditions. Strength training shows promising benefits for executive function, which is your ability to plan, focus, and switch between tasks. A 2020 systematic review in the British Journal of

Comparing Cardio and Strength Training for Brain Health

[04:40] medicine, found that resistance exercise training improved multiple aspects of cognitive function in older adults with strong effects on executive function and memory. So which type of exercise is better for your brain? Let's look at three different situations. For immediate mood enhancement, cardiovascular

[05:00] provides a faster mood boost due to rapid neurotransmitter changes. Effects typically last two to three hours after exercise and intensity matters. Moderate to vigorous activity shows the strongest effects. For long-term emotional resilience, both types are beneficial but work differently. Cardio is

[05:20] cells at anxiety reduction and stress management, strength training shows superior effects on self-esteem and confidence. Combined training provides the most robust protection against depression. And then for cognitive function, cardio is better for memory and learning speed. Strength training has an

[05:40] edge for executive function and attention. Both types help prevent age-related cognitive decline. The combination appears to be the most effective for overall brain health. Although both forms of exercise offer unique benefits, combining cardio and strength training may provide the most comprehensive brain

How to Combine Cardio and Strength Training for Optimal Brain Health

[06:00] health benefits. So here's how you can combine both types of exercise for optimal brain health. Of course, you should always consult your healthcare provider before starting a new exercise regimen if you have a medical condition that could limit your exercise tolerance. Here's a sample six-week workout plan if you're just starting out.

[06:20] In week 1 to 2, start with 10 to 15 minutes of walking three times a week. Add basic body weight exercises like wall push-ups and chair squats. Focus on proper form and breathing. Then weeks 3 to 4, increase walking to 20 to 30 minutes. Add resistance band exercise.

[06:40] include balance exercises like standing on one foot. Then in weeks five to six, begin interval training if you're comfortable with this, progress to more challenging strength exercises, and add a fourth day of exercise if your energy permits. If you're an experienced exerciser, aim for

Key Considerations: Intensity, Recovery, and Progress

[07:00] three cardio sessions a week lasting 30 to 45 minutes each, two strength training sessions, and mixed intensities throughout the week, and at least one full day of rest. Here are three important considerations for maximizing brain benefits. One, intensity matters, but consistency matters more.

[07:20] Modern intensity is sufficient for brain health, and high intensity can provide additional benefits but isn't necessary. Missing occasional workouts is normal. Aim for 80% consistency. A second point. Recovery is essential. Sleep is when your brain consolidates exercise-related

[07:40] changes. Proper nutrition supports both brain and body adaptation and listen to your body and adjust intensity as needed. And third, progress gradually. Increasing too quickly can lead to burnout and allow four to six weeks to adapt to new routines and track your progress

Common Exercise Barriers and Practical Solutions

[08:00] to stay motivated. Now here are three common obstacles and solutions. If you have time constraints, break exercise into shorter durations. Use lunch breaks for quick walks. Combine strength training exercises with your daily activities. If you struggle with motivation, schedule workouts like you would do important

[08:20] Find an exercise buddy to keep you accountable and track your mood to see improvements. The improvement reinforces the importance of exercise. If you have physical limitations, start with seated exercises. Use water exercises for joint problems and work with a physical therapist if needed.

Final Recommendations: Finding a Sustainable Routine

[08:40] The key message here is that both cardio and strength training offer unique complementary benefits for brain health. While cardio might be better known for mental health benefits, strength training deserves equal attention in your exercise routine. The best exercise program is one that you can stick with consistently.

Next Topic Teaser: Exercise and ADHD

[09:00] start where you are, progress gradually, and mix both types of exercise for optimal brain health. In our next video, we'll explore how exercise specifically helps the ADHD brain focus better. Thanks for watching today. Remember to subscribe and hit the notification bell so you don't miss the next video in this series.

[09:20] See you next time.